Charlie Bertsch (cbertsch) wrote,
Charlie Bertsch

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Case In Point

Alright, here's my first "reject" metaphor, doubly problematic because it's probably coming several years too late.

The discourse of "open source" technology, strenuously promoted by my friend Annalee Newitz among others, served as the foundation for what I regard as a key metaphor in Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri's Multitude, when they briefly consider the possibility of an "open source society." I wrote about this passage in my review of the book for Tikkun.

Anyway, I've been thinking, distractedly, about the way in which this concept of an "open source society" might provide a new angle on the phenomenon of personal blogging. Could it be that some of the discomfort people I respect have expressed with regard to weblogs like this one or kdotdammit's or siyeh's or songsiheard's derives from their sense that personal blogs make too much of the "code" that makes us function public? That is, do they worry that the transparency that personal blogs seem to promote constitutes a "security risk" because it makes it too easy for hostile parties to attack us?

Leaving aside the question of whether the confessional mode of the personal blog actually results in more revealing revelations than more superficially guarded forms of communication -- many critics of personal blogging overlook its performance aspects -- I think it might be a usefully "stupid" thought experiment to play with the idea that it represents an "open source" approach to personal identity.

For one thing, pursuing this metaphor would give us a way to think about the peculiar form of "gift-giving" that predominates in many personal blogs, including this one. Maybe the impulse to make our private thoughts public arises derives from a desire to be "hacked." Maybe we confess because we want someone to work on our "code" for us. Maybe we're trying to force our associates to collaborate knowingly in the formation of our own individual identities. It would certainly explain why personal blogging fits the definition of "passive aggressive" communication so perfectly.

  • Anti-Climax

    As I wrote the other day, I had been hoping that the Roger Federer-Rafael Nadal semifinal at the Australian Open would be the highlight of the…

  • An Exercise in Futility?

    As a longtime fan of Roger Federer, I was delighted to see him make the semifinals of the Australian Open. Knowing his opponent would be Rafael…

  • Playing Catch-Up

    It's funny what makes a difference at stressful times. I haven't recorded much television, really, since we lived in California. Somehow we managed…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.