Log in

No account? Create an account
De File
Does Collecting Make You Feel Dirty?
On a day when more destructive protests against the cartoons of Mohammed are in the news together with further developments in the Abu-Ghraib torture story, I was very, very glad to be able to read something illuminating and strong on my Live Journal "Friends" list:
What is the problem with constructing such a narrative in which particular subjects must first be "civilized," or cultivated (to use a particularly loaded nineteenth century term), in order to enjoy "rights" which claim human equality? The contradiction is apparent in the statement itself: supposedly we are all "equal" and therefore must all be represented as such in order to live in "free" society, yet some people are not yet ready for this kind of freedom. This notion of having to first prepare oneself to be equal actually negates the initial contention of equality, designating human concerns as significant only when they come from "developed" interests or parties. This essentially relegates the "not yet" subjects to a less human space, what Chakrabarty has aptly termed the "waiting room of history." Seated in that waiting room (or tied with a chain around one's neck, or seated with woman's panties covering one's head and then photographed, take your pick), marked by degrees less human and conveyed readily through various narratives and images, are Iraqis, Iranis, Muslims of all backgrounds, and countless others. The racial and economic factors undergirding who is in this waiting room paint a disturbing, yet by no means new story about power; the fact that the waiting room has become self-evident or commonsensical--"Of course they need to become ready before they rule themselves"--exposes western hegemony in a frightening and dehumanizing moment.
Thank you wondrousbeauty for bringing civility and insight to discourses that generally lack them.

Tags: ,

4 comments or Leave a comment
From: catfishvegas Date: February 15th, 2006 03:51 pm (UTC) (LINK TO SPECIFIC ENTRY)
cbertsch From: cbertsch Date: February 15th, 2006 04:50 pm (UTC) (LINK TO SPECIFIC ENTRY)
I'm overbooked, unfortunately. Next week, though, I'll make it happen. Either Monday or Wednesday.
flw From: flw Date: February 15th, 2006 06:08 pm (UTC) (LINK TO SPECIFIC ENTRY)
I am sometimes (not in this case, though, it is well-written) amazed by the Left's attempts to justify actions of the Right in the Left's Terms. Whenever people ask questions like, "How can you justify this?" the Right's answer is always the same: They don't need to. They're right.

Period. God is with us. End of fucking story. That's how they think. They're fucking animals. Not animals, but Cro-Magnon in their outlook. They are primitives. But the Left being capable of empathy tries to understand. Stop trying to understand psychopaths, I say... They're fucking psychopaths! That's why they act that way.

Empathy is as Empathy does. If someone has no empathy, don't waste your empathy on them.

(but that makes you the same as them... and so on and so on.)

All I ever mean to say is "We're Right! and they're wrong. PERIOD." Fumble, futz and categorize all you want... it's great, it's important to do. But in the end, never forget to say, explicitly, "THAT'S WHY WE'RE RIGHT and THEY'RE WRONG."
From: wondrousbeauty Date: February 15th, 2006 07:02 pm (UTC) (LINK TO SPECIFIC ENTRY)
Thanks for linking to me here, and for your comments on the post. It was strange to wake up this morning and read the news stories you also link to, having gone to bed after writing that post.
4 comments or Leave a comment